The Christian and Divorce
1. The Biblical passages on Divorce:
a. Matt. 5:32: “but I say to you that everyone who divorces his wife, except for {the} reason of unchastity, makes her commit adultery; and whoever marries a divorced woman commits adultery.”
b. Matt. 19: 9 "And I say to you, whoever divorces his wife, except for immorality, and marries another woman commits adultery."
c. Mark 10: 11-12 “And He said to them, ‘Whoever divorces his wife and marries another woman commits adultery against her; and if she herself divorces her husband and marries another man, she is committing adultery.’"
d. Luke 16:18 "Everyone who divorces his wife and marries another commits adultery, and he who marries one who is divorced from a husband commits adultery.”
2. Interpretive Issues:
a. The Greek word for “unchastity” and “immorality” in the exception clauses in Matthew is “pornias” which is a general rule for immorality not “moicheuios” which is the specific word for adultery.
b. The exception clause occurs only in Matthew, which was the gospel to the Jews. It does not appear in Luke or Mark. Which means the Gentile readers of Mark (the Romans) and Luke (The Greeks) had no exception at all. All divorce was prohibited.
c. In Acts 15:29 the same Greek word, pornias is used with what may be a unique meaning. Read…what is the problem with this passage…would Paul be exhorting apparently obedient Gentile Christians to abstain from sexual immorality? They would have already been abstaining. Some believe therefore that this passage has a restricted meaning to pornias. Here it is believed to be an exhortation to abstain from marriage to near relatives.
3. Interpretations of the Exception Clause:
a. The exception clause is speaking of adultery in marriage. If one partner commits adultery the other partner is free to divorce and remarry.
i. Problem: The word is immorality and not adultery.
ii. Problem: The passage says does not give the divorced person freedom to remarry. Just the opposite is true
iii. Problem: Mark and Luke contain no exception clause.
b. The exception clause is speaking of the marriage of believing Christians, if the divorce took place before you became a believer the divorce is forgiven when you come to Christ and the new believer is free to remarry.
i. Problem: In most of the passages examined the Lord quotes the creation account in support of marriage. In marriage God joins even unbelievers together in a one flesh union. Marriage is for all Adam’s children, not simply believers. This means the restriction would be in effect over unbelievers as well.
c. The exception clause is speaking of the Jewish period of betrothal (one year period under contract between families). It only applied to Jewish people. There is therefore no exception for divorce today (in accordance with Mark and Luke’s gospels).
i. Problem: This interpretation depends upon a culturally restrictive meaning of pornias in Matthew’s gospel unique to the Jews. This is practically impossible to prove.
ii. The possible restrictive meaning in Acts 15:29 is not indicative of a restrictive meaning in Matthew since the audiences are polar opposites (Acts to Gentiles, Matthew to Jews)
d. Divorce is never God’s will. God takes no pleasure in divorce in anyway. The scripture says God hate divorce (Malachi 2:16). God desires each partner to persevere in marriage regardless of the circumstances. In marriage God brings two people together into a one-flesh union (Mark 10:7-9). Divorce rips this union apart and is never a good thing. God however permits divorce in the case of sexual immorality on the part of one party. This is permission not a command and should never be entered into lightly.